Have you had a client show you a lash casting video and ask, "Can you do this for me?" It's a fair question. The videos are gorgeous, the lashes are long, and the caption usually promises they'll be even longer next month. Here's the thing to explain to her: lash casting is a product, and a lash lift is a service. They solve different problems, and only one of them is still working when she wakes up tomorrow.
What is lash casting?
Lash casting is a mascara, typically a gel-based one. Like a tubing mascara, it coats each lash in a thin film that sets as it dries, and that film is what gives the lashes their lift and definition for the day. Many casting formulas are sold as Korean beauty products, which is why "Korean lash casting" and "Korean lash lift" get mixed up so often. (Same country, very different jobs. One is makeup, one is a salon appointment.) For more on the service side, my post on the Korean lash lift covers it.
User reviews of casting mascaras are mixed. Some people love them. Others find they still need to curl their lashes first to get the look in the ads, which is true of many tubing mascaras too. And whatever it achieves, it's gone at the end of the day and has to be applied again tomorrow.
What about the growth claims?
A lot of the excitement around lash casting comes from marketing, and some of that marketing hints that the product will help lashes grow longer or fuller. Lash serums make the same kind of promise. It's worth knowing what the research actually says before a client spends her money on it.
Here's the short version. The lash growth that's been proven in clinical trials comes from a prescription medication, bimatoprost, which was originally developed as a glaucoma eye drop. A 2023 review of eye cosmetics by the Tear Film & Ocular Surface Society (Sullivan et al., 2023) pulled together the randomized controlled trials on eyelash growth products, and nearly all of them tested that prescription drug, not anything you can pick up at the beauty counter. Even the prescription version comes with known side effects, such as redness, itching and darkening of the skin around the eye.
What about the over-the-counter serums? The same review explains that some of them get their results by borrowing a cousin of that drug, a prostaglandin analog, often listed as isopropyl cloprostenate. (The review's tip: look for "prost" in the ingredient list.) Those serums can carry similar side effects without the warnings a prescription has to print on the box. Sweden banned prostaglandin analogs in cosmetics in 2013, and US regulators have warned serum makers whose "longer lashes in 30 days" style claims crossed the line into drug claims. Serums without prostaglandins, the review notes, condition the lashes so they look longer and thicker rather than actually growing them, and popular folk remedies like castor oil have no research showing they affect lash growth at all. A 2024 review of eyelash serums in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology (Baiyasi et al., 2024) lands in the same place: the evidence for bimatoprost is strong, other prostaglandin analogs need more study, and the non-prostaglandin ingredients show "promising data" but still lack formal evidence for lashes. It also points out that US law doesn't require over-the-counter serums to prove they work, or that they're safe, before they go on sale. (If a mascara could grow lashes, trust me, I'd be wearing three coats to bed.)
Mascara, casting formulas included, works a different way: waxes, pigments and fibers cling to the lash and make it look longer, thicker and darker. That's real, it's just temporary. It isn't growth.
What a lash lift does instead
A lash lift doesn't add anything to the lash or promise to grow it. It reshapes the client's own lashes into a curl that lasts, so the length she already has finally gets seen.
Think of a straight line pointed right at you. From the end, all you see is a dot. Curve that same line upward and suddenly you can see the whole length of it. Straight lashes work the same way: from the front, a lot of their length is hidden. Lift them into a curve and they look longer, because now you can actually see how long they are. (Same lashes, better angle. It's basically good lighting for your eyes.)
A few other differences clients notice:
- No daily curling step. The curl is built in, so there's no lash curler and no reapplying every morning.
- It lasts. A lift lasts about one lash growth cycle, roughly six to eight weeks, which is also the range the TFOS review gives. My post on how long a lash lift lasts explains why it fades the way it does.
- Add a tint for drama. Lifted lashes show their length; tinted lashes show it in color, right down to the pale tips. Together they give a "did she just put on mascara?" look with no mascara at all. See my post on tinting after a lash lift for how to time it.
One honest note, because the same review raises it: a lift is a chemical service done right next to the eye, and reactions to lifting solutions and adhesives do happen. That's exactly why it belongs with a trained, licensed artist. Patch test ahead of the appointment following the product directions, check contraindications, and keep every product off the skin and out of the eye. (Nobody wants to be the cautionary tale in next year's review.)
So which should your client choose?
If she wants a little extra definition for a night out, a casting or tubing mascara is a perfectly good bit of makeup. If she's tired of curling, coating and removing every single day, and she wants her natural lashes to look their longest from the moment she wakes up, that's what a lash lift is for.
And if she arrives asking which serum will make her lashes grow, you can tell her honestly: the evidence isn't there for the cosmetic ones. What you can offer is a service that shows off every millimeter she already has. (Usually that's the moment she books the tint too.)
Want to add lash lifts to your menu? Elleebana's One Shot, Elleeplex Profusion and Brik & Pearl systems all lift natural lashes, and our training and certification courses show you how, step by step.
Questions about a product? Ask Ellee, our product expert at polymorphbeauty.com, or reach out to me directly.
